I tried Google, tried Ebay, Amazon and various auto part online stores to no avail

i don't want to paint the lenses either....i already have headlight covers and want to match it with taillight blackouts. any help would be appreciated

matrixracing.com has light tints so you can black or red them out. cardomain.com or andysautosport.com might have some parts too. and keep trying motors.ebay.com something might come up ;)

I would try ebay... it maybe a used one... but it will cost alot less

I think instead of matching with the same colour you can try different combination which will be more attractive.